Why People Actually Quit Their Jobs: 5 Critical Reasons Leaders Need to Address
Did you know that by 2030, approximately 20% of today's workforce will retire? This demographic shift, coupled with the lowest population growth since the census began, creates a perfect storm for organizations struggling with employee retention. By 2034, there will be more people over 65 than under 18 in the workforce. These statistics aren't just interesting data points—they represent an urgent wake-up call for leaders everywhere.
High turnover rates leave organizations second-guessing everything from their recruitment strategies to their company culture. But here's the good news: understanding why people actually quit can empower leaders to develop organizational strengths they never thought possible.
A recent Better Up 2022 study identified five critical reasons why employees leave their jobs—and surprisingly, salary ranks lower than most employers believe. In this article, we'll explore these key reasons and provide actionable strategies to address them before they lead to costly turnover in your organization.
The Demographic Shift Leaders Must Prepare For
The 10-year forecast for the workforce presents challenges that cannot be ignored. With 20% of the workforce retiring by 2030 and the lowest population growth since the census began, organizations face a talent shortage unlike anything we've seen before.
By 2034, demographic projections show more people over 65 than under 18 in the United States. This unprecedented shift means the competition for skilled workers will only intensify. The decisions you make today about employee retention directly affect your organization's ability to navigate this challenging landscape.
As one leadership expert bluntly puts it, ignoring these trends is where "stupidity meets scary." Many leaders acknowledge these issues but delay addressing them, saying, "I'll deal with them when they come." The reality? These issues are already here, and organizations without strong retention strategies will find themselves at a severe disadvantage in the coming years.
Companies that proactively address the root causes of turnover now will position themselves to thrive when these demographic shifts reach their peak. Those that don't will be scrambling to fill positions in an increasingly competitive market.
Reason #1: Salary Isn't Actually the Main Issue
Here's a statistic that surprises most leaders: only 12% of people leave their jobs strictly for money reasons, according to 2019 research. Yet approximately 80% of employers believe money is the primary reason employees quit. This disconnect reveals a fundamental misunderstanding of employee motivation.
In reality, salary functions more as a "permission to play" standard—it needs to meet a certain threshold to keep employees from looking elsewhere, but exceeding that threshold doesn't necessarily increase retention. Once fair compensation is established, other factors become much more important in the decision to stay or leave.
As noted by Dustin Pead in The Culture Base Podcast, "A lot of people are willing to stick with a company that can't afford to pay them what both parties agree that they deserve. They're willing to stick with that company because all of these other things have those needs have been met."
This doesn't mean compensation isn't important. Rather, it suggests that simply throwing money at retention problems without addressing underlying cultural issues is ineffective. Organizations should ensure their compensation is competitive within their industry, but recognize that salary increases alone won't solve turnover problems if the other four factors aren't addressed.
Instead of focusing solely on salary increases, leaders should have transparent conversations about compensation limitations while emphasizing the other benefits and growth opportunities available. This honesty often resonates more with employees than vague promises of future financial rewards.
#healthyworkplace #workculture #companyculture It can be terrifying to deal with a constant revolving door of team members. Turnover leaves you second-guessing everything within your organization. But if we get down to knowing why people actually quit, it can empower us to new strengths we never thought possible. We help leaders know what they’re about, show where they’re going, and develop scalable teams to get them there. #healthyleaders #leadershipvsmanagement #employeeretention #truthatwork #scalable #worklifebalance #teamworkwins
Reason #2: Limited Career Advancement
Consider this real-world example: A high-performing employee left Amazon despite excellent compensation because they couldn't see a clear path forward. This illustrates a crucial distinction that smart leaders understand: positions may top out, but people don't.
"Positions do top out, but people don't top out," as Blake Behr stated in the podcast. Every employee has untapped potential that continues to grow, even when traditional advancement opportunities seem limited by organizational structure.
Even in flat organizations with few management positions, leaders can create advancement pathways through:
Skill development programs that prepare employees for future roles
Special project assignments that expand capabilities
Cross-training opportunities that build versatility
Subject matter expert designations that recognize mastery
Mentorship roles that develop leadership capabilities
The key is communicating these growth opportunities clearly without making promises that can't be kept. Many leaders fall into the trap of being overly vague about advancement ("great things are coming!") or making specific promises they can't guarantee ("you'll be manager within two years").
Instead, effective leaders create individual development plans that identify specific skills, experiences, and knowledge employees need to advance. They schedule regular career conversations—separate from performance reviews—that focus exclusively on growth opportunities and aspirations.
Organizations that excel at retention make employee development a strategic priority, not just a nice-to-have benefit. They recognize that when employees see a future with the company, they're significantly more likely to stay, even when offered higher salaries elsewhere.
“Positions do top out, but people don’t top out.”
Reason #3: Disrespect and Lack of Appreciation
This factor might be the most blatant culture killer in organizations today. Disrespect manifests in both active forms (public criticism, dismissive language, interrupting) and passive forms (excluding people from important communications, not acknowledging contributions, failing to listen).
Gallup's research reveals a startling insight: employees who receive just one positive interaction with their direct superior in the past seven days are significantly more likely to remain engaged and loyal to the organization. This finding demonstrates how little it actually takes to make employees feel valued—and how devastating the absence of appreciation can be.
Respect goes beyond simply being "nice" to creating true psychological safety. As noted in the podcast, "Respect goes a long way. You don't have to be best friends with everybody that you work with, but you do have to respect them."
Leaders often underestimate how their behaviors are interpreted. What a manager might see as "direct feedback" can be experienced as demeaning criticism by an employee. This difference in perception creates what leadership experts call "the story in their head"—the narrative employees develop about their value to the organization based on their interactions with leaders.
Organizations with high retention rates train their managers to:
Recognize contributions publicly and regularly
Provide constructive feedback privately and respectfully
Listen actively to employee concerns and ideas
Address interpersonal conflicts before they create a toxic environment
Demonstrate appreciation through both words and actions
When employees feel respected and appreciated, they develop a psychological connection to the organization that significantly outweighs the allure of slightly higher compensation elsewhere.
“Respect goes a long way. You don’t have to be best friends with everybody that you work with, but you do have to respect them.”
Reason #4: Childcare Challenges
The modern workforce has fundamentally different expectations regarding work-life balance than previous generations, with childcare representing one of the most significant concerns for employees with families.
Organizations that dismiss childcare concerns as "personal problems" project outdated thinking that alienates talented employees. Today's workers expect employers to recognize and help address the full spectrum of challenges they face, including family responsibilities.
While not every company can provide on-site childcare facilities, there are numerous ways organizations of all sizes can help:
Flexible scheduling that accommodates school hours and childcare availability
Emergency backup care programs or stipends
Childcare flexible spending accounts with employer contributions
Partnerships with local childcare providers for preferred placement or discounts
Parental leave policies that exceed legal minimums
Interestingly, financial literacy training can also help address childcare challenges by helping employees better manage their resources to afford quality care. This approach demonstrates that the organization recognizes the interconnected nature of employees' professional and personal lives.
Even companies with limited resources can make a significant difference by simply acknowledging the challenge. Leaders who say, "We understand childcare is a major concern, and while we can't solve it completely, here's what we can do..." show empathy that builds loyalty.
The most forward-thinking companies recognize that supporting employees' family responsibilities isn't just compassionate—it's a competitive advantage in retention that pays dividends through reduced turnover costs.
Reason #5: Lack of Flexibility
The COVID-19 pandemic fundamentally changed how employees view time as a commodity. Having experienced greater control over when and where they work, many employees now see flexibility as a non-negotiable aspect of employment.
Flexibility is deeply connected to autonomy—the sense that employees have some control over their work lives. Research consistently shows that autonomy is a primary driver of job satisfaction and engagement.
Flexibility encompasses more than just remote work options:
Flexible starting and ending times
Compressed workweeks (e.g., four 10-hour days)
Results-based performance measures rather than time-based monitoring
Ability to take time off for personal matters without excessive justification
Control over how work is accomplished (not just when and where)
Setting clear expectations about flexibility from the beginning of employment is crucial. Organizations get into trouble when the offered flexibility is ambiguous or unevenly applied across the organization.
Even in roles that traditionally haven't offered flexibility—such as manufacturing, healthcare, or customer service—innovative companies are finding ways to provide some degree of choice and control. Examples include self-scheduling systems, shift-swapping platforms, and input into work processes.
Leaders who resist flexibility often cite concerns about productivity or fairness. However, data overwhelmingly shows that appropriate flexibility increases productivity rather than reducing it. The key is focusing on results rather than activity, and creating clear accountability structures.
The Power of Belief in Your People
The Robert Rosenthal Harvard study from 1965 offers a profound insight into employee performance and retention. In this groundbreaking research, teachers were told that certain randomly selected students were likely to show significant intellectual growth. Despite these students being no different from their peers, they actually demonstrated superior performance simply because teachers expected it.
This "Pygmalion effect" operates powerfully in the workplace. Leaders who genuinely believe in their team members' potential elicit better performance than those who view employees with skepticism or low expectations.
Connection is a "contagious" force in organizations. When leaders demonstrate authentic interest in employees' growth and success, this attitude spreads throughout the culture, creating an environment where people want to stay and contribute.
Perhaps most importantly, addressing culture can't be delegated. As emphasized in the podcast, "Don't just pass culture off to anybody else. That is passing off maintenance in the environment of your organization to somebody else because you don't want to deal with it."
The garden metaphor perfectly captures this reality: "When you don't tend to garden, you get weeds. You don't get nothing. You get weeds." Culture requires constant attention from the organization's highest levels.
Taking Action to Reduce Turnover
Understanding why people quit is only the first step. To meaningfully reduce turnover, leaders must take specific actions to address each of the five critical factors:
Beyond Salary: Conduct a compensation review to ensure your pay scales are competitive, but also develop and communicate your total value proposition that encompasses growth, culture, and purpose.
Career Advancement: Create individual development plans for every employee that outline possible growth paths, even if traditional promotions aren't immediately available.
Respect and Appreciation: Implement a formal recognition program and train managers on effective appreciation techniques that align with different employee preferences.
Childcare Support: Survey your employees about their specific childcare challenges and develop at least one new policy or benefit that addresses the most common concerns.
Flexibility: Evaluate each role to determine what types of flexibility are possible, and create clear guidelines that managers can consistently apply.
Remember that workplace culture is a business metric that directly impacts your profit margins and company valuation, not just a "soft" HR concern. Organizations with strong cultures consistently outperform their competitors financially.
The organizations that will succeed in the coming decade aren't necessarily those with the biggest compensation packages or the trendiest perks. They're the ones that have thoughtfully built cultures where people feel valued, respected, and able to grow – workplaces people simply don't want to leave.
Take a moment to assess your own organization against these five factors. Where are your retention vulnerabilities? What small steps could you take today to address them? The future of your business may depend on your answers.
Don't wait for the demographic shifts to force your hand—start addressing these five critical factors today and build an organization that attracts and retains the best talent in your industry.
Ready to build a workplace culture that attracts and retains top talent?
Fill in the form below to download your free "Scalability Playbook: Proven Methods For Building High-Performance Teams.
